Science

Do Brain Training Games Actually Work? What the Research Says

From the 2010 Nature study to the FTC case against Lumosity and the 2016 review of the field: an honest look at what brain games can and cannot do.

It's a slightly awkward question for someone who makes a brain training app to answer, but I think you deserve a straight one. Short version: brain games reliably make you better at brain games. Whether they make you sharper at everything else is much less clear, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something. Here's what the research actually says, with links so you can read it yourself.

The big online experiment (2010)

In 2010, Adrian Owen and colleagues ran one of the largest tests of brain training ever, with thousands of volunteers recruited through a BBC programme training online for six weeks. They got better at the tasks they practised, but showed little improvement on untrained tests, even ones that used similar thinking skills. The paper, "Putting brain training to the test", was published in Nature, and it's a good read.

The scientists' statement (2014)

A few years later, a large group of psychologists and neuroscientists signed a statement organised by the Stanford Center on Longevity and the Max Planck Institute for Human Development, objecting to marketing claims that brain games could reverse cognitive decline. You can read the consensus statement on Stanford's site. It's worth noting that a different group of scientists replied with an open letter arguing some training does have benefits. The field genuinely disagrees at the edges.

The FTC and Lumosity (2016)

In January 2016, Lumos Labs, the maker of Lumosity, agreed to pay $2 million to settle charges from the US Federal Trade Commission that its advertising made claims it couldn't support, such as helping people perform better at work and school and delaying age-related decline. The FTC press release is short and readable. I go into what this means for choosing an app in Habz vs Lumosity.

The big review (2016)

Later that year, Daniel Simons and six colleagues published a long review of the evidence behind brain training products, “Do ‘Brain-Training’ Programs Work?”. Their conclusion, roughly: there's extensive evidence that training improves performance on the trained tasks, less evidence for closely related tasks, and little evidence that it improves everyday cognitive performance. They also pointed out weaknesses in how many studies were designed.

Where the evidence is more positive

It isn't all gloomy. The ACTIVE trial followed nearly 3,000 older adults who had a few weeks of training in memory, reasoning or processing speed, and found the trained abilities improved and some benefits lasted for years. You can browse the papers on PubMed. The World Health Organization's 2019 guidelines say cognitive training may be offered to older adults, while being clear that the evidence is limited.

So the fair summary is "some specific benefits, for some people, with plenty of uncertainty", not "useless" and not "miracle".

What I take from all this

  • You'll get better at the games. That's real and satisfying, but don't read it as a higher IQ.
  • Be suspicious of big promises. If an app claims to prevent dementia or boost your IQ, look for the study. Usually there isn't one that says that.
  • Enjoyment matters. The value I'm confident about is a pleasant daily habit that keeps your mind busy and replaces a few minutes of doom-scrolling.
  • Brain games are not the main event. Exercise, sleep, hearing, blood pressure and social life have much stronger evidence. See what actually helps your brain.

How this shaped Habz

It's why Habz never claims to raise your IQ or protect your memory, and why it's free. I didn't want to charge for promises the science doesn't support. What I do promise is 38 practice games that are fun, quick and get harder as you improve, twelve longer Journey puzzle games with 200 levels each, and ten daily puzzles that are the same for everyone. If that sounds good, here's what each game trains. For background reading, the Wikipedia article on brain training is a decent, well-referenced overview.

Habz is on Google Play

The app is the best way to play: it's faster, works offline and keeps your streak going with reminders. Still free, with no ads.

Install the app

Habz is on the App Store

The app is the best way to play: it's faster, works offline and keeps your streak going with reminders. Still free, with no ads.

Install the app